Opinions please on logos

[ScootchsMom]

Can you ladies please look at these logos and tell which you like? I'm leaning towards a certain one, but I'm not going to say so I can get an unbiased opinion

1.

2.

3.

4.

Thanks for your help!

Liz

See my latest post for computer question about the logo......

[Neshama]

I like the second one...

[Annie]

I like them in this order
1
3
4
2
-Annie

[douladot]

I'm going to be difficult here -- hee, hee --- I like the artwork in #1 and the logo in #2 (Helping Families Grow).

[ScootchsMom]

Quote:

Originally Posted by douladot I'm going to be difficult here -- hee, hee --- I like the artwork in #1 and the logo in #2 (Helping Families Grow).

Hee Hee What about the artwork from #1 with the wording from #2? I'm doing this myself so I can play around with it.

[Annie]

Quote:

Originally Posted by douladot I'm going to be difficult here -- hee, hee --- I like the artwork in #1 and the logo in #2 (Helping Families Grow).

I didn't even notice the difference in Mothers and Families. I agree I like Families better.

-Annie

[ScootchsMom]

I changed it to this:



What about the color? Is it too harsh in black and white? I don't know what else would look nice but still be readable.

[missilla]

i like the one that you last posted!! it is beautiful. simple and elegant. did you do that by yourself? and how. the whole logo thing is killing me.

[douladot]

Quote:

Originally Posted by ScootchsMom I changed it to this: What about the color? Is it too harsh in black and white? I don't know what else would look nice but still be readable.

I think this one is perfect just the way it is!! Way to go!

[ScootchsMom]

Quote:

Originally Posted by missilla i like the one that you last posted!! it is beautiful. simple and elegant. did you do that by yourself? and how. the whole logo thing is killing me.

I got the graphic from istockphoto.com (royalty free pictures you can buy for pretty cheap) and I'm using paint.net as the editor. The program is a little confusing, but its a free download and is similiar to photoshop. I can't afford photoshop, it is WAY too much money for me! I thought I'd give it a try myself before paying someone to do the logo.

[emmabella]

I like #1 and #4. They are two very different directions though. Number one I think clients would respond the best to. Number four is the most graphically impactful. Whichever you choose I think you need to make the text part of the logo larger so it is balanced with the graphic. If you choose the mom/baby line drawing then it would be neat to see the "Lily Doula Services" font in a color but keep "helping families grow" black. I'm a big fan of having taglines in a plain text font too. Meaning "helping families grow" would be a non-fancy font like Arial or Tahoma. It gives emphasis to the main business names and is more readable when shrunk down to fit on a business card.

[Lyndsey]

I like #1 but with the phrasing "Helping Families Grow".

[Lyndsey]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Annie I didn't even notice the difference in Mothers and Families. I agree I like Families better. -Annie

Quote:

Originally Posted by ScootchsMom I changed it to this: What about the color? Is it too harsh in black and white? I don't know what else would look nice but still be readable.

Oops, I didn't finish reading the replies before I replied. I like this one.

[Mile High Doula]

I like #3 best. Color is almost always better. #1 is nice but kind of plain.

[BirthLove]

I like 2 and 4.. 2 is a little busy but really pretty, and four is plain simple and elegant!